I also leads me to think - would anyone be acutely embarrassed by my disclosures here? I remain anonymous on most fronts, I try to be sincere and authentic. I think before I write. But is blogging somehow a lapse in judgement? I know some bloggers have told me that they would like to blog in complete anonymity so that they could really go to town on what they feel. I get that vibe...but ultimately, for me the best blogs are the ones where there is a real and genuine person behind it.
Every now and then I forget how much I have told you about myself. I go back and read old posts and realise that in fact I am like an open book at times, spilling my feelings as if the route from keyboard to screen to worldwide Internet is just a hop, skip and jump from my innermost thoughts.
What news stories like this remind me of is that blogging is still considered a quirk; something that bored women do to fill their days. Another case in point, Mary who writes Mary Loves told how her husband's friend, on hearing of her blog, commented that she needed to get a hobby. This made me cross! Maybe deep down in me there is this feminist sensibility that feels that being down on women who blog was a bit like being down on women who wrote in the 19th century. George Eliot used a male pseudonym as she would never have been published as her female self. Can you imagine that now? Errr, this is starting to feel like an essay I would have written at University!
In summary I sense that the interrelationship between blogging, money and feminism may be slightly too weighty a topic for a Wednesday morning, so I will say only this. It's a shame that blogging gets people into hot water and it's a shame that so many people judge it and don't 'get it'. As for me it's been lovely all the way through; I have nothing but good to say about it. Long may it last!
![]() |
| all lovely images via bippity boppity boo |









Crikey, I hadn't heard about Austerity Mum.....I have to say that I loathe Mumsnet tho, it does seem to attract a particular "type" of mother.
ReplyDeleteYou make some really good points as usual though. I have to say that I hadn't thought of the link between blogging and money....or that bloggers are predominantly female, which they probably are. I need to think a little more don't I?!!
If you like it do it I say....if it is making you happy, then blog away. I too like those where I "know" something of the blogger....I read and enjoy Mary's blog for example. The only anonymous blog I can think of is Dustjacket Attic...she gives nothing away about herself but then that's not really what her blog is about but somehow the tone of her blog is still lovely and she isn't talking about personal issue anyway.
On a totally different note, I saw "Black Swan" last night.....OMG! You have to see it...incredible!!! xx
Here, here...
ReplyDeleteBlogging has only ever been a positive and enriching pastime for me. I think there has to be a reason to blog whether it be personal or professional. I blog because it keeps me writing and most importantly blogging keeps my creative energies up... but more importantly it is a forum where like minded souls can share their passions. xv
Lou..I read about Austerity Mum as well and wondered how she must have felt having to sign off. It has caused quite a stir. Part of me felt she should have not been so naive to think that no one would guess her identity especially with the depth of information she was giving. If someone is planning to go undercover and be totally anonymous they have to be pretty savvy at it because it would not take much for people in the know to find them out. I think of all the open doors I have left in my own blog and there are many.
ReplyDeleteThe flip side is that like us, she enjoyed it and it filled her life with something that was meaningful to her. I am sure she must feel the loss and so much more. Should she have carried on and rallied is what I wonder...she is a communications guru, could she have spun it another way? I hate the thought of defeat. So, as you can see I am of two minds as well. Is live and learn the moral for her?
Blogging...just for women? I think it depends on the topic. There are quite a few men out their with a voice too. I wonder if someone would tell them to get a hobby? Opps...I think you have just discovered something about me...a feminist at heart?
Could be my immersion into Lark Rise to Candleford with Dorkas Lane
and her feminine sensibilities. I was cheering over this one last night...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_YYmylrm2p8
Such a clever lot we are :)
Great post Lou...as always!
Jeanne ( Big Sis) xxx
Thank you for a thought provoking post. I only vaguely read the headline about 'Austerity Mum' but I've read about one other blogger who stopped because she felt her readers had expectations of her she could not - did not want to meet. I have to agree that it's just very sad. No one was harming anyone and if it gave them a creative outlet or whatever it is/was valuable enough for them to give that time to it, then they should be left in peace to get on with it. But then I do err towards the live and let live motto.
ReplyDeleteMy blog is as anonymous as I can make it without it being 'faceless' mainly because I talk about my children in it. I do not talk about personal details - that's just common sense isn't it, but I hope I don't express too strong an opinion - or + (except when receiving crumple trousers in the post!!!).
Maybe it's a question of balance as with a lot of things. It sounds like you have yours here and thank goodness for that! Yes, long may it last! Thanks again.
Lou a perfect post for my reflective wednesday morning...
ReplyDeleteall i'd like to say though...is....
life is made up of moments that make you feel every emotion under the sun....
if blogging makes you feel anything other that happy free positive and comfortable then it's not the forum for you...
finances, marital woes and information that may hurt, upset or ridicule others is not for the forum i know as *blogging*....
is there no-where women can express themselves without ridiculous comments such as *she needs a hobby*...
as usual Lou....you eloquently state what most of us think....& thank you for that....
melissa xxx
p.s loooving the book!!
Yes, long may it last!!
ReplyDeleteI tripped over mumsnet a few times in my early pregnancy, and I soon decided to stay away. I imagine them to be the kind of women who read Heat and Closer on end, revelling in other people's 'shortcomings'.
The comment of that husband's is just so wrong, I don't know where to start. MMxx
Wonderfully said, as always. I didn't get upset by the comment, really - I realize that it was said less in judgment than in lack of understanding. And that's fine. He doesn't need to get it. When I started my blog, I decided at the start that it would be for me. If people get it and like to read it, then that's all the better. I do think it's more fun to make connections with like-minded people. As for the points on disclosure, it's such a fine line that everybody draws for themselves. Some people seem to be much more comfortable sharing information than others. I am fine sharing pictures of my family and cute things they said or did, but I completely understand why others are not. And there are a lot of things I am not comfortable sharing online. For me, I stay positive, and it truly does serve as a sort of 'gratitude journal' for my life. I've gotten several comments since posting that, encouraging me to keep up what I'm doing, and that's exactly what I intend to do! Long my it last! :-)
ReplyDeleteDear Lou, what a hoo har!! I know Lisa (Austerity Mum) and she is from that. What a terrible shame - her blog was great fun!
ReplyDeleteIt's hard to know what to reveal and what not. I just witter on about whatever I think of that day. I feel it's fine as long as I'm not damaging anyone else.
I hope this week is better for you xx
I'm with you all the way...blogging is a bit of a release for me and I enjoy the interaction with others. Despite the fact I'm anonymous (I hope), I don't think I really write anything that could hurt others. I felt sorry for "Austerity Mum" and it's a shame I never got to read her blog - think I would've enjoyed it x
ReplyDeleteIts a push/pull for me. I tend to hold everything in (a bit of the opposite problem) , trying to put on a false front for others with a "everything's fine and pretty mentality" So I made it a goal last fall to try to be more authentic in my daily posts and I have seen a difference ... My readers seem to respect me more and dare I say enjoy me more? So I still hold back some things , the personal things. things about my health or husband I would only share with a close few. But otherwise finding my authenticity in blogging has been rewarding. Thanks for your thoughts.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your post. I would have liked to have read austerity mum it was her escape and enjoyment and I think it was written in a tongue in cheek manner. I have just joined the blogging world and would like to think that I could comment and give an opinion and that people will accept me even if they disagree. It reminds me of people who complain about tv programmes my view is there is an off button use it. I hope she returns to the blogging world in time.
ReplyDeleteLou, you know what is funny. Last night I fell asleep to many thoughts about writing a post like this one you've done here. Until you blog, and have a blog of your own it is so hard to understand what it's all about and what having a blog really makes you feel. Not classifying blogging as a hobby? Well that's an issue with no doubt, many many layers that I hope I can one day address but my goodness if I had to ever delete mine I would be devastated. I guess I will do a post on this eventually. You have inspired me as you always do. Lots of love to you my sweetness xoxox
ReplyDeletei hadn't heard of that story - thank you so much for sharing! and you make a very interesting point about the suppression of women's voices and the blogosphere. it's an interesting thought that there are so many female bloggers out there, many of which have personal elements to their blogs. historically, groups that have their voices suppressed in the mainstream arena and in mainstream mediums find unique means of self-expression - and oftentimes more profound ones. beauty comes from struggle after all.
ReplyDeleteand feminism is my favorite way to start my wednesdays :) thank you.
An interesting post Lou. Like Rhiannon, I think that until you blog it's very hard to understand the vast community of bloggers and what they each contribute. So usually I find criticism comes from a lack of understanding.
ReplyDeleteI'm also one of those anon bloggers, but I'm very private in life, so I guess that's just me. I so admire others such as yourself who have a way with words and can share like this.
xxx
As always Lou, beautifully put. It's like we're chatting over coffee when I read your posts - love it! I know what you mean about it all but I don't think you have anything to worry about. I so get that feeling sometimes that some people we know feel like I'm some kind of privileged Lady What Lunches who fritters her time away indulging her writing about fashion when really, she should be out earning a proper keep! Only a few and I may be getting them wrong but they definitely dont get it.
ReplyDeleteOver time you learn to rise above it.
I feel a bit put off about Mumsnet. I was going to join for the sake of the Style Advice Service but I just dont know. Keep hearing bad things about it!
We'll thrash it out over real coffee as opposed to a virtual one next time we meet up! When by the way???
Need a Lou fix!
xxxx
Love this post Lou. I too read about Austerity Mum... in light of the banking chaos, I imagine PwC just wanted her silenced... at the end of the day, she was also dragging her families private life across the internet (namely her husband), I know my hubby gets a little fidgety if he or the kids appear too often. If she loves blogging as much as we all do, she can always bounce back under another alias... although I imagine the British press would hunt her down and draw her blood once more... As for this old blogging malarkey, I feel that there is an incredible amount of talent out there and this is the perfect outlet for all these amazing people that would otherwise remain undiscovered! It certainly beats buying magazines! Lx
ReplyDeleteInteresting read. I suppose when we blog we are putting ourselves out there. It's all a bit of a risk. I blog under my actual name, I have at times considered whether that's wise, or not, but at the end of the day I don't want to write under a nom de plume. I am who I am. Nothing is going to change that. However it does mean I have to be careful about what I write, which can be frustrating. Uhm. I do enjoy blogging, and I enjoy my private life - it's all about been selective I suppose. I did once have a catty comment off a friend saying something along the lines of, 'I suppose you're going to blog about that then?' ...I don't think it was meant quite as I took it, but still uhm... Food for thought! Selective, and cryptic is the way forward. xx
ReplyDeleteNew follower here.
ReplyDeleteYou have a beautiful blog.
I love that white dress.
Ladaisi Blog
Great post Lou ~ as per usual of course. Not many of my friends know that I have a blog but I cherish the friendships I have made here. I try not to divulge too much but I know sometimes I may give away too much ~ but I want my posts to be a true reflection of myself and not some fake typing away... I cannot imagine having to delete my blog as it is an outlet for me in many ways. Something to think about for sure. xo
ReplyDeleteWow, what a fabulous post! I don't have anonymity with my blog but, I have been asked by a few not to post pictures of them or talk about an experience with them (and I have honored there request - to an extent). There are some things I don't discuss: work and something private of someone else's. And I like to think I am an "ethical" blogger. Unfortunately, I haven't heard of these other bloggers and I am sorry that their "cover" was blown but, then again maybe they shouldn't have written about some of the things they did...just a thought.
ReplyDeleteGreat post. And a lot to think about. I like to be transparent but also feel compelled to not say too much. But for the most part most days I'd like to say more than I do. I think there has to at least be some level of honesty and real life in order to connect with you're readers. And you are certainly very good at that!
ReplyDeletexo
That "husband's friend" has me rather pissed off. The nerve!
ReplyDeleteAnd, like you, I love the authenticity behind a blog. The voice, if you will, must be real and one I can relate to or it's a no go for me.
Great post, Lou!
Carrie
My Goodness! I hadn't heard of that story and instantly feel a great sadness for Austerity Mum. How on Earth was her cover blown and by whom? What a mean act of insensitivity and rudeness..
ReplyDelete'Mumsnet'.. what a horrid name. Clearly labeled by someone who feels threatened by the creativity, brilliance, and bravery that all bloggers display every day, as they/we share our life and inner most thoughts openly.
Blogging takes courage and integrity in my opinion, at least the ones worth reading, and I agree with you in that the lovelies ones are those with real and tangible people behind the pretty banners!
Biggest hugs for you, your beautiful blog and for sharing so generously with us!
xx Charlotta
I'd not heard about Austerity Mum until I read your post - goodness people have been quite nasty about her....perhaps she was just being tongue-in-cheek, it always astounds me when something like this brings out the worst in some people and they use to jump on their own personal bandwagon. Anyhoo I digress - I enjoyed your thoughts on blogging....as for 'getting a hobby' perhaps blogging is the hobby? And perhaps blogging is the modern version of a journal - albeit a public one? I've been thinking lately that the connections one makes through blogging is perhaps a modern version of pen-pals.... Certainly people tend to fall into the 'get it' or 'don't get it' category when it comes to blogging....
ReplyDelete